“Wisdom Cries Out in the Street”

 A sermon preached with the people of St. John’s Episcopal Church in Oakland, California.

Video is available on YouTube and text is below.

Wisdom (Hokmah in Hebrew, Sophia in Greek) cries out in the street. She raises her voice in the public square. At the busy intersection. The center of town. She is a goddess figure. A prophet figure. A mother figure. She is the wisdom of our God, personified.  

I imagine her out there with a protest sign, marching steadily, unafraid to offend. And her words are offensive. They are cutting. “Because I have called and you refused, have stretched out my hand and no one heeded, and because you have ignored all my counsel and would have none of my reproof, I also will laugh at your calamity,” she says. “I will mock when panic strikes you.”

If you don’t listen to me, I won’t be here when you come calling, she says. It’s not gentle. It’s not nice. It is desperate. A desperate call in a desperate time for God’s — for her  — children — to learn that their actions have consequences. And that their words have consequences.

The Book of Proverbs, an admittedly complex and sometimes contradictory collection of material, is clear on the consequences of our words, specifically.

It is wicked to quote “concoct evil,” (16:21-28) we are told. “He who does evil listens to the lips of wickedness,” (17:4) we are told. “The lips of the fool will bring strife,” (18:6-8) we are told.” “A worthless witness will mock justice” (19:28). And perhaps most clearly, “Death and life are in the power of the tongue” (18:21).(1)

This collection of writings that first started to take shape from oral tradition over 1000 years before the birth of Jesus and over 3000 before the birth of social media tells us that words can be a matter of life and death. Our words have consequences.

And boy have seen that truth at play this week.

This week, wicked words jumped from the unverified mire of the internet to the national stage of mainstream media. Words that told us people – immigrants. Immigrants of color. Immigrants from Haiti. In the city of Springfield, Ohio … were eating pets. It feels terrible to even shape those words in my mouth. It feels shameful to have said them out loud. I feel Wisdom standing right here. Arms crossed. Head shaking.

And I must tell you these wicked words seemed kind of funny at first, at least to my ears, and maybe to some of yours too. Ridiculous. Cartoonish. So obviously untrue as to be hilarious. No I did not believe for a single moment that these words were true. But I did believe they were funny in that deep untruth.

So, I sat safely and silently behind my glowing screen and laughed at the memes and tiktok sketches, and the cartoons and jokes and humor pieces about how ridiculous these words were. And I drowned out the sound of Wisdom’s cries. I drowned out the sound of Wisdom’s threats. That words have consequences. And that these words were not funny. They were deadly.

And I learned that Wisdom knows that these are not new words. They had hurt and they had killed before. The Washington Post reported this week that “Stereotypes about immigrants eating dogs, bats or rats have long circulated in the United States — beginning during the wave of Chinese migration in the 1800s.”

“My first thought was: Here we go again,” said Anita Mannur, director of American University’s Asia, Pacific and Diaspora Studies program. “This is a trope we’ve seen time and time again that is used to ‘other’ people of color [and] new immigrants.”

“Here we go again,” Wisdom cries out in the street.

This week, Springfield municipal buildings were evacuated as a result of threatening emails. On Saturday, Springfield hospitals were placed on lockdown.

Wisdom cries out in the street.

On Friday, the schools for the second day in a row due to credible threats of violence. High school students. Middle school students. And elementary school students.

Wisdom cries out in the street.

All week, regardless of school closures, some Haitian families kept children home, and some chose to send them. “My niece was scared, but I told her to go, that God would protect,” said one Haitian resident.” Some Haitian families are choosing to completely upend their lives and move elsewhere. “I’m going to have to move because this area is no longer good for me,” one resident said. “I can’t even leave my house to go to Walmart. I’m anxious and scared.”

Wisdom cries out in the street.

Springfield Mayor Rob Rue said: "All these federal politicians that have negatively spun our city, they need to know they're hurting our city, and it was their words that did it,”

Wisdom cries out in the street.

On Thursday, a group of local community and faith leaders gathered in Springfield. The diverse group were there to testify to what their faith traditions tell them about love and justice for all people. The Rev. Dr. Michelle Boomgard of Christ Episcopal Church started out by telling the crowd that Jesus taught us to love our neighbor. All of our neighbors. As a first-generation American herself, she then dispelled the lies being told about the Haitian community in her city, and she spoke about who these beloved children really are. Later, she posted on Facebook, “PLEASE STOP SPREADING THE MEMES. Yes, some of them are funny. But, every one of them adds fuel to a fire. And those of us who live in this city want that fire to stop.

Wisdom cries out in the street.

What did you hear from Wisdom this week? I’d love to hear about it. I heard that meeting wicked words with mockery, as I was compelled to do, is not enough. And may even be harmful. That when I hear wicked words, I am called to bear witness to their wickedness with my own, carefully-chosen words, which I have tried to do today. And say what I know to be true.  

This morning Jesus asks his disciple two questions. The first is “Who do people say that I am” and the second is, “who do you say that I am.” It strikes me that this exercise of closely examining the differences between what some people say about God or any child of God’s true identity, and what we say can be clarifying. I pray that when I find a fundamental difference there, I will learn to find my way through the mockery and the laughter, which is more comfortable, and to the truth-telling and testimony.  

In this case, I will testify that some people say that the Haitian people of  Springfield, Ohio are deceitful, dreadful, dangerous and inhuman. I say that the Haitian people of Springfield, Ohio are beloved children of God, and that their presence in a struggling town has led to positive outcomes of all kinds.

I name the wicked words that I will not repeat again as racism. As white supremacy. As xenophobia. As fear-mongering and dangerous. As violent. As words not to be taken lightly or joked about. As death-dealing.

Other than being clear with our words, how can we — a people called to love our neighbor as ourselves — respond to Wisdom’s desperate cry in this desperate time? Boomgard urges those who want to help her city to “consider contacting your politicians. Ask them to end the harmful rhetoric that targets immigrants, and to seek solutions that build infrastructure and education for all people, so that we can live and work together with dignity.” In addition, she commends us to the Haitian Community Help and Support Center in Springfield. This is a ministry by and for Haitians You can find out more about them and donate online.

Wisdom cries out in the street.

(1) Carole R. Fontaine, Fortress Commentary on the Bible, “Proverbs.”

Kathleen Moore